![]() |
|||
| Not noxious! | |||
It was a tall and pretty thistle plant that I was admiring when someone drove up, jumped out of their car without putting it in park (it kept rolling a bit), and told me that I needed to cut it down because it was a Canadian thistle and a noxious weed. She was very vigilant. And motivated. I was taken aback. I told her, sweetly, of course, that it was the national flower of Scotland and that I wanted to see it bloom first. I assured her that I’d make sure that the flowers didn’t turn to seed. She seemed somewhat mollified. However, I wasn’t.
I took to the internet in a fact-checking frenzy. My daughter and I eventually identified the plant as a Scottish thistle which is not a noxious weed in this state; it is in some others, though. The Canadian thistle is a noxious weed in this state, but our lovely flower was most definitely not a Canadian thistle. There are a number of obvious differences between a Canadian thistle and a Scottish thistle.
I’ll admit it, though. It is rather weed-like. But it’s not noxious, so we can cultivate it if we care to. It did turn out quite nicely. In England, you can buy a Scottish thistle bush and plant it in your garden. Obviously in a land overrun with gardeners, there would be fewer noxious weeds.
Anyway, you can see that big bulb on it, can’t you. We didn’t think that you could press the flower like it showed William Wallace doing in Mel Gibson’s Braveheart. So, we cut one and put it between some leftover bricks. You can see the results. That big ol’ bulb flattened right out. But look at the bloom! It lost all of its delightful color! So, I think that I found an error in the Braveheart movie. William Wallace’s pressed thistle supposedly retained its color, but I think it was due to movie magic instead of botanical science. Just a guess.
![]() |
|||
| pressed, colorless thistle | |||
I looked on YouTube for Braveheart clips that included the thistle, but could only find a clip of young Murron picking the flower and giving it to young William at the funeral of his father. Her picking the flower is amusing since picking a Scottish thistle is not as easy as she makes it look. It’s extremely prickly, which my daughter and I found out when we tried and succeeded in bringing in a bouquet. And it did take both of us to cut and handle the stalks. And yes, it did hurt. I imagine, judging by its prickles, that it’s not meant to be picked.
Flower of Scotland is about the thistle. Can you believe there’s a song about it? I found it out when searching around YouTube for the above-mentioned clips. It’s my understanding that the “Proud Edward” mentioned in the song is Edward II who fought against Scottish King Robert the Bruce in 1314. He was the son of Longshanks if I’m understanding it correctly. Here’s a link in case you want to hear the song. I guess that it’s sung by Scots before rugby games. There are tons to YouTube clips of that.






